Skip to content
Home » Blog » If you want a conversation, start with a question

If you want a conversation, start with a question

    two old men deep in conversation outside a cafe

    Why leading with questions rather than evidence is the secret to collaborative conversations

    I studied the history of science as an undergraduate, but clearly I wasn’t paying much attention. I remember learning about Socrates, but I only recently discovered that he never wrote anything down. Not a single book (or scroll or whatever). Everything we know about him was written down by other people, notably Plato. This wasn’t just an oversight or the result of an overzealous Greek de-clutterer throwing everything out. Socrates thought that writing things down weakened the memory, and that debate was the most effective way to learn.

    Too many facts can shut down discussion

    Now obviously it’s just as well that someone wrote some of his thoughts down or we’d never have heard of him. But I am with Socrates to a certain extent. When we write things down in black and white, especially in an academic book or journal, they suddenly take on a quality of irrefutable truth and reverence. It shuts down debate and deliberation.

    Sometimes shutting down debate is exactly what we want (who else would like to draw a line under so-called ‘debates’ about man-made climate change?). But what if we want to open up debate rather than shut it down?

    I often say that I’m not especially interested in black and white, I’m all about grey. I like to discuss things and understand all the nuances and different perspectives. And a lot of the conversations I facilitate are all about the grey areas too.

    Start with curiosity rather than a lecture

    It’s only through conversation that we can really understand where other people are coming from. One of the most impressive engagement tools I have ever seen is called the Human Library where participants can ‘borrow’ a person for a conversation. It is an incredibly powerful way of breaking down stereotypes, prejudices and discrimination.

    It works for research too. Engaging stakeholders, negotiating with collaborators, finding common ground with a community group, convincing policymakers – try starting with a conversation, rather than a lecture, and see what happens. And if those conversations are really tricky or you need someone to hold that space for you, reach out. I can definitely help with that.

    Photo by Juri Gianfrancesco on Unsplash

    This post is adapted from an email sent to my Gathering with Purpose newsletter list. Subscribe below to get more insights like this in your inbox.